Carter & Cheryl Orlet

How Cheryl Orlet and Her Family Cope

With Trigeminal Neuralgia

By Kathleen Sweeney

Cheryl Orlet is an amazing mother of three, two boys and one girl, of which one of the boys and the girl are twins. Although she is a TN Warrior, as we call them, she still manages to attend almost all of their soccer and baseball games and competitions. Her daughter is a dancer and when she is competing Cheryl tries to fix her hair and her makeup but her hands shake too much to do it. Other mothers help out by telling her to sit down and let them get her ready. It is this kind of support that carries her through. “The noise at those competitions is just so loud! I sit there just trying to smile for her. I put on a brave face. I don’t want her to see how much pain I am in. I have amazing friends who help me out so much.” But she worries that her suffering is affecting their childhood. Her deepest concern is that she is somehow robbing them of the carefree years all children deserve. They worry that their mom isn’t feeling well and that they might be making too much noise or are disturbing her in some way, causing her pain to worsen.

It all started seven years ago in 2011. “I was having an ungodly amount of pain that I think I stayed awake with for four days straight … just crying.” She could not get relief. She went to the emergency room and they sent her to an ENT doctor who sent her to see her dentist. Everything came up clean there so they sent her to her primary physician. As she told him “… there is this invisible line drawn down the middle of my face. The right side is just – I’ve never ever felt pain like that before. Even after having gone through two C-sections and having root canals done, I’ve never been in so much pain.” He told her it sounded like Trigeminal Neuralgia and referred her to a neurologist who gave her so much medication that she couldn’t function … and he just kept upping it. So she quit him. She finally found one she really liked and he gave her trileptal, which has minimal side effects. She wasn’t as groggy and tired. It allowed her to function. As she says, “The most important part for me is, I can suffer …  and put up with a lot, but I hate anything that takes away from my kids.” She doesn’t want to miss out on anything that happens in their lives.

Cheryl is a registered nurse. “The absolute worst thing about this disease is that not a lot of people are educated on it. … When I was in nursing school we literally learned about it for five minutes. It was a paragraph in our book when we did the section on neurology.”

Whenever Cheryl has to go to the emergency room and tell them she has trigeminal neuralgia they tell her they can’t find it in their system so they put her under headache or migraine. “It’s not a migraine. It’s the most ungodly amount of pain you could ever imagine. Some of them look at you like you’re a drug seeker, just there to get a fix. I am there as a last resort!”  On one particular day there was nurse who saw her and said she had never heard of trigeminal neuralgia but had just had someone else come in with it. She said they were asking for dilaudid, an opioid, and she wondered if that was a reasonable request. Cheryl responded “This pain is real. It is real!” The nurse was just amazed that she had two patients there with TN and she had never heard of it before. It is in these situations that she tries to raise awareness. “It needs to be made more aware. I love raising awareness for it. I just hope some money starts going to it.”

After three years of living in pain she decided to try surgery. She told her husband “This is how bad this disease is. I am so desperate I am willing to go into brain surgery.” But she was excited because she thought this could be “it”! On September 15, 2014 she had micro vascular decompression surgery. They found that an artery had adhered itself to the nerve. The surgeon was able to scrape the artery off of the nerve and then he put a Teflon pad around the nerve so that another artery wouldn’t or couldn’t do the same thing. She was supposed to be there for three days but was actually in the hospital for 10 days overall (3 days in ICU) with complications.

Her children came to see her after her surgery and she was asleep when they arrived. She awoke hearing her daughter crying. She was staring at the staples in her mother’s bald head behind her right ear. She said “Mommy are you OK? Are you going to be alright?” Although they had talked about it beforehand you just can’t really prepare children for such a thing. Her oldest son didn’t know what to think about it so he wrote his story (his version of her story) for a school project, which helped him to cope. He won First Prize and his story will follow this one, for you to read. He was in fifth grade at the time.

When Cheryl got home from the hospital she had about three weeks of relief. “A little bit of relief” is how she describes it. She was highly medicated and recovery was “just awful. Every time I sat up I would throw up.” Her symptoms returned and at times she thinks her trigeminal neuralgia was worse since she had the surgery. When I asked if there were any benefits at all she responded “No.” She has Type II, which means the pain is constant. And at times it is even worse. Washing her hair, her face, combing her hair, drinking, sweating, all increase the pain. And then there’s all the medicine. She can’t eat yet it makes her gain weight. She hops on the treadmill to work out which starts her sweating and then the sweat rolls down her face.

She started taking trileptal in 2012 and it was new to her. She has had success with it but she also needs baclofen due to her inner ear pain. “The pain is just so deep. Right between my inner ear and the roof of my mouth.”

But again, what makes the pain that much worse is the way it affects her kids. They pick up on how bad she is hurting and it hurts her to know this. When it gets really bad her right eyelid swells shut. Her children will ask “Mom do you need me to get you a heat pack?” or “Can I get you something?” “Do you need anything?” The worst is when they are kids being kids. Her twins will be jumping around and all of the sudden they just stop and freeze. They turn and say “Oh mommy. Is this making your head hurt?” Or when her daughter who has asthma gets coughing hard and makes herself stop to apologize. “Mommy, I’m so sorry. Is this coughing hurting your head?” Cheryl tells her “You are a little girl with asthma. Don’t worry about me. I’m the mom. I need to be worrying about you. Don’t worry about anything you do. I’m worried about you.”

One day she passed out at work, the pain was so horrible. She collapsed and they sent her to the hospital. Her neurologist thought a University doctor might see something he didn’t or have some idea of something else that might work … just to get his opinion and see if there was anything they hadn’t tried. He was good (they said the best!) but when he saw her chart he told her she was on what she needed to be. That her best bet was pain management and since there is no cure so, basically, this is your life. Just go day by day with the pain management drugs. When she went back to her neurologist because she was having more symptoms she was told she was no longer a patient since she went to another doctor (whom he recommended). That was quite a surprise to her as she found herself without a neurologist to work with. He general doctor has since taken over and doses her trileptal. He works with her; he believes her pain and he has become a good friend. But she still can’t believe the other one just let her go after all they had been through together.

For Trigeminal Neuralgia Awareness Day on October 7, 2015, the Belleville News Democrat newspaper did a story on Cheryl. It is in a bigger town next to hers. She just really wants to raise awareness! She sells shirts with Trigeminal Neuralgia on them and donates the proceeds to the Facial Pain Research Foundation. She also wears them so people will ask her what it is so she can tell them about it and that she sells them to raise funds for research. She has had people stop and say to her “I have that too.” She loves to raise awareness of it.

Her husband has been a colossal help. She hasn’t done the laundry in at least six years because it is too painful to bend over. When he would have a headache or a toothache he would ask her “Babe, how do you do this every day?” Now he just asks it out of the blue. She says “You do what you have to. It affects every single day of your life. There’s just not a day without pain. It’s ‘How bad is it going to be today?’ ‘Is it a day I can even get out of bed?’ Or is it I’m going to be in the middle of doing stuff and I just have to get through that. Luckily I have an awesome support system. … I think if it wasn’t for my family there would be a lot more days in bed.”

Although Cheryl has tried acupuncture and a number of other things, people always seem to have some advice to give of some thing new she should try. She says she is scared to try anything because she doesn’t want it to get worse. She can’t imagine being in any more pain than she is in now and she is not willing to take that chance.

She worries that she is stealing her children’s childhood; that her pain is affecting them in some negative way. “You just try to be as happy as you can and not let your kids see the tears. They worry about me so much and I don’t want them to. I want them to just be happy kids and not tell their friends when they come over to not be too loud cause ‘I don’t want to hurt my mom’s head.’ I don’t want that. I don’t want them to look back on their childhood and say ‘my gosh, mom was sick all the time.’ She never used to miss anything but this past year has gotten so bad that she had to miss things. Her children say “I get it. I get it Mom.”

“Luckily I have a job where they are understanding. I’m an administrative nurse. I do scheduling and a lot of paperwork and just make sure that all goes well. I’ve been at my job for 20 years. I started in the kitchen and I worked my way up to Nursing Director. If it wasn’t for them I wouldn’t have a job. They know when I’m not feeling good. They’ll say ‘Go home! Go work from home.’ There are some days I can’t even sit upright in a chair.” When she thinks “I can’t do this anymore” she recalls how “I busted my ass to get through nursing school. It was HARD. I haven’t been doing all this work for Trigeminal Neuralgia to rob me of my medicine career. Something I’ve been wanting to do forever.”

When asked what she would say to someone who just had that jolt of pain for the first time she said first to find a medicine regimen that works for you. Don’t be afraid to stand up to your doctor. If you can’t find agreement with him or her find a new one. Definitely join a few support groups on Facebook. Get involved and raise awareness.

“By all means possible take the negative and turn it into a positive.”

Carter’s First Prize Story in Fifth Grade

            Webster's Dictionary defines "incurable" as "not likely to be changed" but my life and my family's life (especially my mom's life) has changed in so many ways in the last 5 years. My mom has a rare and incurable disease called trigeminal neuralgia and this is her fight and our family's journey.

This all started one morning when she woke up. When she woke up she had horrible facial pain. She tried taking medicine like ibuprofen and Tylenol but nothing helped. After a couple days she still had pain so my dad took her to the ER and the doctors just didn't know what to do. They decided it would be best for my dad to take her to the ear, nose, and throat doctor. I was very confused why they weren't just taking her to another hospital. During this time I was just ... confused. I barely knew what was going on and why she was having this pain. When she came home from the doctor they said that she needs to see her dentist.

That evening she got into the dentist. After examining her he determined that there was no problem with the gums or teeth that would cause her any pain. The dentist said that she just needed to go see her doctor. She has seen him for many years and she trusts him.

The next day my mom was able to get in to see him, my mom explained to him that she was in such bad pain she couldn't bear it. She described her pain to him and she said "if you drew a line down the center of my face, it's the entire right side of my face that is in horrible pain, especially the inner ear and the roof of my mouth". She then went on to tell him about how she couldn't sleep and walked around our house at night because she couldn't sleep because she was hurting so bad. He looked at her and said, "I'm afraid you have trigeminal neuralgia". They talked about different medicines she could take to reduce her symptoms, there is no cure for the disease but there are medications that can reduce some of the pain and other symptoms such as relaxing the nerve. He prescribed medicine for her that people with seizure disorders take. He told her that she should try to find a neurologist. Prior to her first visit with her new neurologist my mom was admitted to the hospital for some pain management. During her hospitalization, she was given steroids and pain medicine and she finally felt some relief.  She remained in the hospital for a few days and she was released with orders to see a neurologist.

Within the week my mom went to see what would be the first of 6 neurologists. All the different medicines he was trying with her made her very tired and it was hard for her to do anything and she slept most the time. Every time she told him that she was in pain he increased her medications. After going back and forth with that doctor many times and disagreeing about treatment my mom went to look for another doctor. The next doctor she saw suggested she have a treatment done called "gamma knife" this is a very precise radiation treatment that is focused on one small area. The doctor wanted to do this treatment to directly access the trigeminal nerve to attempt to numb the pain or at least decrease it. After a lot of testing they said she wasn't a candidate for the gamma knife treatment. It seemed like she would get so excited only to be disappointed, sometimes it was hard to see her so upset. This doctor referred my mom to another doctor across the river.

I remember my mom came home very upset from this appointment, the doctor was very short with her and would not listen to all of her symptoms. This doctor wouldn't give her time to tell her story and he pretty well just blew her off and wouldn't allow my mom the chance to speak. He did at least order an MRI to look for any abnormalities which came back

OK and that was frustrating also, she didn't want anything bad to show up but she did want some answers. So that was another doctor gone which left her with no doctor.

There were few other neurologists that she saw that were also one­appointment doctors. Even though all this was so frustrating she was always happy. Between Mid 2013 to August 2014 my mom was in the hospital about every other month. These times were the hardest and I would miss my mom so much. We would go to the hospital to visit and dad would say "I know this is hard guys but please don't cry in front of your mom it may upset your mom more" and when we got to the hospital we could tell mom was being strong even though I could tell she was in pain and was missing us. Mom would smile, hug us, and ask about our days and school and our activities. It was hard not to get sad or scared when I saw the IV's and monitors hooked up to her.

One good thing did come from all these times in the hospital, she found a really good neurologist and she really liked him. He helped her find new medications with few side effects which was good for us because she wasn't as tired and could do more stuff with us. After many more times in the hospital, he introduced my mom to a neurosurgeon he worked with. He was also very nice and wanted to help, the first time he met her he said, "don't cry I'm going to help you". My mom came home excited that she had found a doctor that would help. In august 2014, after being in the hospital again, she decided to go in and have brain surgery.

According to my mom what the doctor was going to do was to go into her skull and the brain and look at the nerves that come out of the spinal cord and look at the trigeminal nerve and see what was going on. The doctor would look and see if there was anything touching the nerve and if there was he would move it away so the nerve wouldn't be affected and that would hopefully stop all the pain.

The surgery was very scary for mom but just as scary for me and dad. Bradyn and Caitlyn were too young to understand. Just hearing brain surgery is scary, mom and dad tried to act like it wasn't a big deal. My mom was supposed to only be gone for three days. My brother, sister and I stayed at my grandma and grandpas house. They tried to keep things as normal as possible like there was nothing going on but we missed mom, dad, our pets and our home. Mom and dad ended up being gone for 10 days, we got to see her one time while she was at the hospital. We walked into her room and it was really scary for us, she was hooked up to all kinds of wires and tubes, they had shaved part of her hair off and there was a row of staples in her head. We were very nervous to go by the bed but so happy to see her. She was happy to see us but she was in a lot of pain. My mom's nurse and pain management doctor had heard so many stories about us that they had presents ready for us, they gave us a bag with candy and a book that had an invisible ink pen, her doctor made us balloons with smiley faces made out of the gloves that the doctors and nurses wear. I felt better about my mom being there after seeing how nice the people were that were caring for her.

When my mom came home she was having a very hard time, her pain was still very bad, she kept telling us that it was going to be okay because she was getting better. Mom spent about two weeks in bed before she could start moving around the house. It was so great having her home because even though she was in bed we could see her every day. So many people were helping us out, I couldn't believe all of the people coming by to bring us dinner and they always brought dessert too! Mom and I would watch movies in her room even when she was not feeling well, just had to make sure not to move the bed too much because it would hurt her head too much. It was a hard time but we were doing good because we were all together, we were just ready for her to feel better and get back to how she was four years ago.

I am sad to say that never happened, mom even says sometimes she thinks the surgery actually made it worse. My mom saw another neurosurgeon to see if anything else could be done and he told her there was no cure for this disease and she has a rare type of trigeminal neuralgia and all she can do is have help dealing with the pain.

My mom took this bad news and turned it into a good thing by teaching others about her disease. Last October the Belleville News Democrat put a story in their paper about my mom, they came to the house and talked to her and put it in the paper. Mom has also been raising money to give to the people that research cures. My mom makes me proud, it is hard seeing her in pain but no matter what is going on she is always there for me and my brother and sister.

THANK YOU PAT AND AMY TOMASULO

AND CHICAGO

LAUGH YOUR FACE OFF Has RAISED OVER $1,200,000!!!

By Kris Gaganidze

The Fourth Annual LAUGH YOUR FACE OFF was held May 8, 2018 in Chicago’s beautiful neighborhood of Lincoln Park at the Park West.  This marks a new date and a new bigger venue!  All of this helped to make this year’s LAUGH YOUR FACE OFF a huge success. With temperatures in the high 70’s and a beautiful sunshine day to come out and help support The Facial Pain Research Foundation (FPRF) in their fight to find a cure for Trigeminal Neuralgia (TN).

To date LAUGH YOUR FACE OFF has raised over 1.2 million dollars for research for a cure for the rare nerve disorder called Trigeminal Neuralgia.  The   Foundation is currently funding six different research programs to find a cure for Trigeminal Neuralgia.  TN is known to be one of the most painful conditions known to humans.  It is often called the suicide disease because there is no known cause and no cure.   

My husband, Kyr and I had the great pleasure of meeting Michael Pasternak six years ago.  He is one of the people who started the Foundation looking for a cure.  We got involved with Pat and Amy Tomasulo four years ago when we were asked to help with LYFO.  What an honor to get to work with and know these amazing people.  They are the brains and Founders of the brilliant LAUGH YOUR FACE OFF! This year’s LAUGH YOUR FACE OFF took place at the Park West Chicago.  The venue was twice the size that we’ve had in the past.  So over twice the number of people (700) attended Saturday’s event.  The evening started with cocktails, appetizers, silent auction and raffle!

My husband and I had the privilege of checking in VIP guests, sponsors and TN patients.  What a joy to thank our sponsors personally and give hugs to TN patients as they entered the event.There was a separate raffle set up just for the TN patients.  I think they appreciated the thoughtfulness of a special raffle just for them!  And a huge shout out to all of the returning and new sponsors!  We appreciate your generosity and support! 

The evening started with the very funny Pat Tomasulo warming up the audience with his great standup comedy.  After Pat got the crowd laughing we never stopped.  He was followed by five, yes five great standup comics.  Thank you to Rocky Laporte, Brian Smith, Jeannie Doogan, Drew Frees and Mike Stanley.

Next, the beautiful Amy Tomasulo read the raffle winners, which was exciting for all of the winners of those amazing packages!  

Followed by two special videos of TN patients, which gave us deep insight and understanding into the daily toll that TN takes on a person’s quality of life.  It’s amazing to see the impact on the audience that those videos made.  It was emotional, inspiring and heartbreaking.  These two brave TN warriors brought tears to many people. 

Then the big give which raised twenty five thousand nine hundred dollars in a matter of minutes!  I continue to be astounded by how generous people are.  

LAUGH YOUR FACE OFF an event where I was surrounded by friends, family, doctors, scientists, TN patients and many supporters.  Everyone was there for a reason, to find a cure for Trigeminal Neuralgia.  Every person I met that evening truly cares about the patients and supporting the research for a cure.  LAUGH YOUR FACE OFF is a huge success because of all the people who show up to show that they care.  Thank you for a beautiful night that gives each and every TN patient hope for a better tomorrow.

Mervyn Rothstein Interviews

 Dr. Wolfgang Liedtke

Wolfgang Liedtke, M.D., Ph. D., is a professor in the Departments of Neurology, Anesthesiology and Neurobiology at Duke University in Durham, North Carolina. He is an attending physician in the Neurology Clinics for Headache and Trigeminal Sensory Disorders and an attending physician in the Innovative Pain Therapy Clinics of the Department of Anesthesiology at Duke. Both as a physician and as a scientist, his focus is on understanding mechanisms critical for pain and inflammation in order to alleviate suffering of patients afflicted by therapy-refractory pain – pain that does not respond to treatment – with the emphasis on trigeminally-mediated pain (trigeminal nerve pain, also head-neck pain), but also other nerve and joint pain. As an attending physician, he has encountered more than 1,500 cases of refractory trigeminal pain disorders, as well as chronic migraines.

The Facial Pain Research Foundation has provided a grant to Dr. Liedtke and the Duke University Center for Translational Neuroscience as one of the Foundation’s projects to find cures for trigeminal neuralgia and related neuropathic pain.  Dr. Liedtke and his group at Duke are exploring how material science and material science combined with cellular engineering can be used to make transmission of neural signals in the trigeminal system normal again.

Mervyn Rothstein, who was an editor and writer at The New York Times for 30 years, now writes the "Stage Directions" column for Playbill.com, and is a former member of the Tony Awards Nominating Committee. His first symptoms of trigeminal neuralgia occurred in 2005.

Dr. Liedtke spoke with Mervyn Rothstein.

MR: YOU ARE BOTH A NEUROLOGIST AND NEUROSCIENTIST.  WHY DID YOU DECIDE TO FOCUS ON PAIN IN YOUR CAREER?

WF: As a junior trainee, I was exposed to pain because of the places where I trained, in Zurich, Switzerland, and in Germany. Programs there were run by expert and master physicians, and I was impressed by how they were able to help patients suffering from chronic pain. And I was also profoundly touched and moved in a very basic human level by the suffering that I saw, and that I could not fail to notice. Seeing how the physicians treated and diagnosed these patients impressed me, and I volunteered to help them from my junior perspective and work with them and do the first interview of the patient. I saw that I could do this pretty well. I have a good feel for it and can communicate well with patients who suffer from chronic pain.

When I shifted more toward basic science in a laboratory setting, I happened to make a discovery that was important and relevant to pain, which was sort of serendipitous because I was aiming much deeper and looking for basic new mechanisms. It turned out that the TRPV4 ion channel, the signaling molecule, which I discovered two decades ago, is a relevant, significant player in pain, also craniofacial pain. We found it expressed in the trigeminal ganglion in small neurons, which meant this could be relevant to pain.

Then, moving to Duke University, for my first independent faculty position, with the lure of being both a physician and a scientist, I decided that pain would be a very appropriate theme for me because it would allow me to practice pain medicine and also move forward my pain-related discovery in the basic science research lab.

WHAT IS THE IMPORTANCE OF YOUR TRIGEMINAL NEURALGIA RESEARCH STUDY AND WHAT POTENTIAL IS THERE FOR HAVING AN IMPACT ON THE STUDY OF OTHER DISEASES AND POSSIBLE CURES?

I’m extremely grateful for the support of the Facial Pain Research Foundation because it enables me to take a project that is at the drawing board stage and has some initial data to it and give it a more solid base under its developing legs.

On the drawing board the imagination was to harness the power of stem cells that we engineer to become a certain type of cell that will help to function as an anti-pain generator and get that specifically engineered cell close to a key anatomical site of the trigeminal system, the cisternal trigeminal nerve root, which is the target of the well-known microvascular decompression operation and is also the target for the gamma knife radiation procedure [two medical methods of eliminating or alleviating trigeminal neuralgia pain]. Rather than operating or radiating we propose to bring cells close to the nerve root and engineering the cells so that they function anti-pain, so that they secrete and produce natural anti-pain modulators. By forcing them to reside close to the trigeminal nerve root, they will calm down and bring down the excitation level and inflammation level in the nerve root and in the entire trigeminal system.

And in positioning these cells right next to the cisternal trigeminal nerve root we will use a material that functions as a holding device. The cell-holding device we will also accomplish what the traditional, good old-fashioned microvascular decompression accomplishes, which is to protect this critical part of the trigeminal system against mechanical injury.

In a parallel approach, while we move forward with “encaged” cells, we will also try to take advantage of a new nanomaterial [material made up of building blocks that are at the nanoscale] that I have done work on previously through my collaborative network here at Duke University, where we have material scientists and chemists and we harness the novel advantageous properties of a model carbon nanomaterial to use as a shield/ wrapping material for the trigeminal system. It could be described as facilitating a neuro-protective environment.

These are the two approaches I’ve articulated and for which I’ve received support from the Facial Pain Research Foundation and which might have significant implications for other types of pain. These approaches could be applied to other nerves that were injured, resulting in nerve pain, for example a lumbar root of the sciatic nerve, the cervical nerve roots that supply the arm or other peripheral nerves (sciatic, ulnar, median). Both methods are translatable to these other types of neural injuries.

WHY HAVEN’T SCIENTISTS COMPLETED THIS RESEARCH YEARS AGO? WHEN SOMEONE ASKS YOU WHY DIDN’T YOU START THE RESEARCH MANY YEARS AGO HOW DO YOU RESPOND?

The conception of these ideas is based on the thoughts and fantasy and imagination one has but also on new theories or other findings that are sprouting up within the field, what you read and what you hear at conference meetings. Microvascular decompression works in a number of patients, not in all, and it has other issues involving it, so I was certainly not the only one thinking about trying to upgrade or make it more contemporary, more focused. What I’m proposing is based on relatively recent findings that I hope to take advantage of. So these ideas weren’t possible before these new findings were made public.

YOU SEE PATIENTS IN PAIN EVERY WEEK.  DO YOU REALLY BELIEVE THAT CURES CAN BE FOUND FOR THIS DISORDER, WHICH IS OFTEN CALLED THE “SUICIDE DISEASE”?

I strongly and profoundly believe that transformative steps can be taken to deal with this form of pain. It depends on the definition of cure. There is the possibility of a so-called miracle cure, where something is done and the patient is totally cured – the pain is out of the life of the patient who was tormented by trigeminal neuralgia. But the miracle cure is harder to accomplish than a decent and what I call a transformative level of pain control, whereby pain is reduced to a level where patients can lead a normal life again, can participate in life and deal with the remaining amount of pain disturbance that the disease still poses. I believe that is something we can accomplish through implementing and translating research for more and more patients.

WHAT ARE THE BIGGEST OBSTACLES YOU FACE IN TRANSLATING YOUR PRECLINICAL FINDINGS TO THE CLINIC?  WHAT ARE SOME OF THE WAYS YOU HOPE TO OVERCOME THEM?

We live in exciting times.  We have so many tools at our fingertips. If only we had the money. That is one obstacle – availability of funding to realize our ideas – not just bold ideas that lead to brave new experimental approaches on the laboratory bench but also something is translatable, and is equally daring or has a decent chance of leading to dramatic advances.

Also there are administrative and so-called red tape obstacles that would not cost a lot of money to overcome - rewriting or redoing the complex rules that govern the scientific research game and especially the rules governing translation into new treatments that will be available to patients. Scientists and doctors can make their voices heard, but this is an involved national and international decision-making process where our views are of limited impact. I am enthusiastic that the Facial Pain Research Foundation is becoming partial to the ways of how to revisit and reform the process.                                           

THE FACIAL PAIN RESEARCH FOUNDATION IS MOVING FORWARD WITH A SENSE OF URGENCY TO FIND CURES FOR TRIGEMINAL NEURALGIA AND RELATED FACIAL PAIN.  WHY HAVE YOU LINKED YOUR EFFORTS TO SUCH A NEW ORGANIZATION IN THE FIELD OF PAIN RESEARCH? AND HOW IMPORTANT IS THE FACIAL PAIN RESEARCH FOUNDATION TO YOU AND YOUR WORK?

I feel privileged and I’m very happy about this association. They are like-minded people. I intend to go after this disease. I attempt to accomplish this goal of transformative change of treatment effectiveness through novel engineered treatments. That is my mantra. And there is nothing hollow about it. Every single letter of that is true to the core of who I am as a professional.

So with that, I notice that the Facial Pain Research Foundation is managed and is driven by people with whom I have zero disagreement in that respect. I am so happy and so proud to be a part of it.

Mervyn Rothstein

Interviews

Douglas K. Anderson, Ph.D.

In 2018 Douglas K. Anderson was the recipient of the US Congressional Certificate of Recognition and The University of Florida McKnight Brain Institute established the Douglas K. Anderson Facial Pain Research Program to fund future research to find cures for TN and neuropathic pain.

Douglas K. Anderson, Ph.D., is eminent scholar professor and chair emeritus of the Department of Neuroscience at the University of Florida, College of Medicine, former director of the McKnight Brain Institute at the University of Florida. He is director of research and a trustee of the Facial Pain Research Foundation. He was interviewed by Mervyn Rothstein, who was a writer and editor at The New York Times for nearly 30 years and now writes the Stage Directions column – a series of interviews with theater directors – for Playbill.com. His first symptoms of trigeminal neuralgia occurred in 2005

Why did you want to be a scientist, and how did you become one?

I had a cousin who was a physician, and he kept after me to go into medicine, saying we would go into practice together. So between my junior and senior year at the University of Texas I got a summer internship at MD Anderson Hospital in Houston, which is a world-class cancer hospital. I was there for about three months, and about a month into it I realized that if I had to make a living as a doctor I would starve to death, because it was difficult for me to work with sick people. I was dealing with pediatric cancer cases and I would go home and cry. But I had spent about half my time working in the research laboratory, and I loved the lab. So I went back to school and changed my major from zoology pre-med to straight zoology. I didn’t tell my parents until Christmas – which was an interesting Christmas. And I went back to Anderson Hospital after I graduated and worked with a Ph.D. instead of an M.D. I got my masters at the University of Houston, and my Ph.D. at Michigan State in 1972.

You worked for 33 years for the Veterans Administration. What kind of work did you do?

I was there from 1973 until I retired in 2006. The V.A. was very good about allowing us to have appointments at medical schools, so I had a dual appointment. I was working on spinal cord injury both with my academic appointments and at the V.A. I was for a year the Department of Veterans Affairs Deputy Director of Medical Research.  

Why after more than 30 years of researching spinal cord injury did you decide to turn your efforts to finding a cure for trigeminal neuralgia?

The main reason was that spinal cord injury was so complex, because the spinal cord is so complex. We were working on locomotor function – movement – which is an incredibly difficult thing to do. Spinal cord injury is a constellation of symptoms – bladder function, sexual function, pain, temperature regulation, so many things. So I decided that instead of trying to hit a home run, I would go after a bunt single. One of the major complaints most spinal cord patients have is pain, and all scientists generally in a situation like that look for the simplest model. I’m not saying that trigeminal neuralgia is a simple model, but relative to spinal cord injury it is. One nerve, a big nerve, and the pain is in that nerve. I became interested in mechanisms and the patho-physiology of pain.

How is the Facial Pain Research Foundation unique from other research organizations?

We try to keep the bureaucracy at a minimum. We try to keep, while diversified, the number of projects we fund to maybe four, five, six at the most. We have a purely volunteer organization. Nobody gets paid anything. Our scientists don’t get paid. Our Trustees don’t get paid. Our support staff doesn’t get paid. I don’t get paid. Ninety-five percent of the money that comes in goes directly to the researchers for the research. I try to look for the best people in their field in the world to work for us. And to work with us.

How were you able to attract top researchers in the world to such a small foundation?

Instead of having them submit a grant, we say, this is what you’ve been doing, give me something we can hang a hat on, then go and do what you think will be exciting. So instead of their having to deal with a bureaucracy and submitting a grant every six months or a year, we, on a small scale, give them the money quickly, give them their leeway and see what they can do.  I call this “money with soul.” This is money given by people directly. This is not some faceless National Institutes of Health grant given with your taxpayer dollars. 

You were chairman of a prestigious neuroscience department and director of the McKnight Brain Institute.  Why is the Facial Pain Foundation’s research so important to you? Is it in part because a solution to neuropathic facial pain would also help provide scientific answers for multiple sclerosis, epilepsy, back pain, and other neuropathic pain?

Yes. I think it has a chance of making a difference. Mother Nature in my opinion is very conservative. The neurotransmitters in the gut are very similar to those in the brain, except you have different receptors and they work in a slightly different way. I look at this, and I think other people do too, as hopefully being sort of a Rosetta stone for pain, for neuropathic pain. Fundamental mechanisms are involved, and I think we can have a broader effect than just trigeminal neuralgia, also maybe diabetic pain and other pains. I think this research has a chance to be bigger than what you might expect it be.

How difficult is it to describe the science and the research to nonscientists?

For me, it is not too difficult. I’ve dealt closely in spinal cord injury and now in trigeminal neuralgia with the patient population we’re serving. I’ve always felt it was important to go to them and try to explain what we’re doing. I just hope that when I simplify it for lay people I’m not overdoing it so that I’m giving them incomplete or false information. 

At the beginning of 2011, the foundation set a goal of finding cures within ten years of establishing its research program.  At a minimum, what do you hope to accomplish before the end of 2020?

I’m hoping we will have a handful of genes or one gene we can hand off to others to test, and do animal studies and see if we can chart models of neuropathic pain by using the gene or the constellation of genes working together. To see if we have pain because they’re not working together, or we have pain because they’re overworking. Also, at the very minimum we hope we will have done human tracking with MRIs to chart the pain pathways that are involved, and locate the pain signal from the nerve to the brain, to where the brain can process it. And once you have that, then you have targets to do your intervention, do your injections. When you see which pathways are involved, you can define the neurotransmitters, so you can attack it that way. We are also hoping that the gene people will have solid data on how complex the gene interactions are – which is the alpha dog gene, or if there is an alpha dog gene, and how the genes interact.  

You wrote the following Facial Pain Research Foundation mission statement:

    “The Facial Pain Research Foundation is to establish a well funded translational research continuum that is dedicated to identifying the mechanisms underlying neuropathic facial pain and to developing groundbreaking therapeutic strategies that will permanently stop the pain of TN and related neuropathic pain syndromes.”

In your opinion, how are the foundation, its scientists, trustees and volunteers doing in relationship to its purposes and goals?

I think we’re doing fantastic, and I’m not someone prone to hyperbole. I’m very careful. I never would have dreamed in 2011 when we had zero dollars that we would now have collected a little more than $4 million. That $4 million has had a multiplier effect and raised even more funds for the research. I find that to be phenomenal. I think we are doing and our scientists are doing a wonderful job and making strong progress. I’m gratified and surprised that we have done as much as we have done in the period we have been in existence. 

First Published Jan 7, 2011

Lucia Notterpek Ph.D, leads Florida researchers who are focusing on damaged nerve coating as key to finding a cure for trigeminal neuralgia

Lucia Notterpek and Douglas Anderson at Facial Pain Research Foundation

Board Meeting January 7, 2011

One known culprit behind the piercing, repetitive pain of trigeminal neuralgia is damage to myelin, the waxy coating that insulates nerve fibers against electrical signals that are transmitted from cell to cell. Loss of myelin on the trigeminal nerve causes a short circuit that results in facial pain.To define how myelin defects cause havoc in the nervous system, University of Florida Neuroscience Professor Lucia Notterpek, Ph.D., is leading studies of myelin biology and disease. She is addressing basic questions about healthy myelin, which is vital to the normal rapid movement of electrical impulses through the nerve pathways, and about various nerve disorders, including hereditary demyelinating neuropathies, which result from myelin defects or deficiency. She seeks information that will aid the development of ways to repair or rebuild myelin in order to cure trigeminal neuralgia and other demyelinating diseases.In one project, she is carrying out experiments in mice aimed at defining the role of myelin-producing genes in nerve disease, and in another more clinically oriented study, she is evaluating the effectiveness of various pharmaceutical compounds designed to protect nerves. New and better compounds are urgently needed for trigeminal neuralgia, since all medications currently prescribed for this disorder have side effects ranging from bothersome to intolerable.

“We’re finding genetically altered mice are a very good model for investigating myelin damage,” said Notterpek, who also chairs the Department of Neuroscience at UF’s College of Medicine. “We have a known genetic defect—specifically a deficiency of the peripheral myelin protein 22 gene that is linked to myelin damage. We can induce temporary nerve compression that mimics the condition in classic trigeminal neuralgia, and we can measure sensory response in the animals. Later, after sacrificing the mice, we can analyze the status of the nerves at the molecular level.” Co-investigator, Andrew Ahn, M.D., Ph.D., an assistant professor of neurology, neuroscience and anesthesiology specializing in the treatment of headache and facial pain, has expertise in assessing pain behaviors in mice. By measuring behavioral responses to mildly uncomfortable stimuli such as heat, researchers can detect abnormal pain behaviors in mice in comparison to responses by healthy mice. Ahn said the sensory responses observed and measured in mice cannot be directly equated to human pain, but a series of behavioral approaches aimed at analyzing the animals’ sensitivity to various physical stimuli can be used to approximate various aspects of pain in humans.

Currently, Notterpek seeks to figure out how the PMP22 gene normally works to help produce myelin, and what happens in disease conditions to cause this gene to get stuck in nerve cells rather than traveling to the myelin sheath where it is needed. She refers to this problem as “mistrafficking or abnormal expression of genes, like a traffic jam in part of the nervous system.”

She said daily, repeated observations of mice with known myelin defects reveal a puzzling observation: under the same testing conditions using the same type of stimuli, some of the mice show hypersensitive responses that indicate discomfort, while others show delayed sensory response. In a testing procedure now well-practiced in the UF lab, mice are placed in a clear box while a researcher shines a warm light on their feet, creating a situation similar to walking barefoot on hot sand. The hypersensitive mice move their feet within two to three seconds, while other mice don’t seem to be bothered by the warmness of the light for longer times. The responses of the animals are monitored and recorded by a computer for subsequent analysis. Notterpek said correlating specific gene deficiencies or gene abnormalities to myelin damage and to indications of pain requires long, tedious research that can involve behavioral assessments in hundreds of mice.

In previous studies that resulted in two published papers, she discovered that mice generally have to reach a certain age before they show signs of myelin deterioration—similar to the way TN most often affects people over age 50. Now she and Ahn are investigating how myelin damage in different parts of the nervous system may result in different levels of discomfort. They note, for example, that longer nerves such as those in the hind legs are more susceptible to damage than the shorter nerves.

Notterpek also is testing a hypothesis that the peripheral nerves in mice with PMP22 gene deficiency are more sensitive to injury, and require little provocation to initiate myelin injury. She seeks to determine the least amount of nerve damage needed to trigger loss of myelin in normal mice, and in mice that are deficient in the PMP22 gene. At the close of each study, the mice are sacrificed, and the nerve is removed and examined microscopically to assess the status of the myelin. The researchers also measure the levels of molecules involved in both the myelin sheath pathway and the pain pathway.  

In parallel studies supported by a grant from the National Institutes of Health, the UF team is testing specific nerve-protective compounds—one well established drug and others newly developed. Through a new pilot study, they are beginning to investigate additional commercially available compounds and dietary supplements that may affect the pathways believed to be important to normal myelin formation. They are just starting to test the effects of these compounds on cells that make myelin.

Notterpek’s myelin research is funded in small part by the TNA-Facial Pain Association, which has its national headquarters in Gainesville. She and Ahn currently carry out the TNA-FPA-supported research with one lab technician and the help of non-salaried students on scholarships. They hope to publish the first major manuscript on their findings in 2011.

Although Notterpek has only been at UF for 11 years, her studies of myelin damage and myelin restoration began almost 20 years ago while she served as a research assistant at the Gladstone Institutes of the University of California San Francisco. After entering the doctoral program in neuroscience at UCLA, she completed her thesis on a topic related to multiple sclerosis. She earned her Ph.D. in 1994, followed by a five-year postdoctoral fellowship in neurobiology at Stanford University. Coincidentally about this time, neuroscientists first identified the PMP22 gene and several other genes that play a role in eroding or chipping away myelin from nerves.

While at Stanford, she became involved in a project aimed at determining more precisely how the PMP22 gene may be implicated in myelin injury. When she left Stanford in 1999, she took this project to the University of Florida where she has been working on nerve damage ever since. Her large research program is aimed at translating discoveries in the mice to applications in patients with trigeminal neuralgia and with hereditary demyelinating neuropathies. In both conditions, damage to myelin disrupts the normal transmission of nerve impulses.

Eminent Scholar Douglas K. Anderson, Ph.D., who formerly chaired UF’s Department of Neuroscience and who supports plans for Notterpek’s research, suggests several approaches to myelin repair might be tested in the myelin-deficient mice. One approach would involve patching the demyelinated region of the trigeminal nerve with myelin-producing cells derived from adult or embryonic stem cells, or with the patient’s own Schwann cells, provided these cells do not carry a genetic defect that produces unstable myelin. (Myelin is made up of Schwann cells.)

Anderson also proposes, “Gene therapy might be used to deliver genes that produce endogenous factors known to control pain and/or to knock out genes found to be involved in causing pain. With this approach, it might be possible to manage the pain of TN without actually repairing, or even identifying, the defect producing the pain.”

Anderson is a trustee and scientific advisor for The Facial Pain Research Foundation, who is helping to establish its international consortium of scientists working to cure nerve-generated facial pain. He is internationally known in scientific circles for his development of the first effective medication for acute spinal cord injury and for his pioneering studies of embryonic tissue transplants to halt complicated wounds associated with paralyzing spinal cord injury in people.

Hi,
I came across this website friday 29th June 2012. I have been researching for around two years now in regards to what could be the cause of my sons sudden pain in his cheek and forehead. My son is called riley, around the age of two riley started with funny episodes where he would get facial pain in his cheek and head. This made him sick on several occasions, he would also sleep for sometime after the episodes. 

Riley has been under his paediatrician since they started who thought possible seizures was the cause. Riley has had EEG, ECH metabolic blood tests and urine samples. All were reported as satisfactory. Riley's last appointment was on Monday 11th June 2012 which his paediatrician left us with no answers and asked us just to keep my son off his wii and see how he goes. He was also discharged, so we was still left in the dark. On Friday 29th of June riley woke crying in pain around 11pm we gave him paracetamol. He cried for around 30-40 minutes, in pain holding his cheek.

Asked me "mum why does this keep happening to me" his voice desperate for answers. Riley was 5 in January, this has gone on for some time now and we are still left with no answers. Having to explain to my 5 year old son that I don't know is just not the answer. I sat frantically trying to research Riley's symptoms on the Friday night. I came across this site where I found a story called Emily's story. Emily's story sounds exactly the same as Riley's.

Riley's and Emily's symptoms are very much the same. I have now written to my sons paediatrician with details so hopefully they can look into TN, I would appreciate any information or advice you can give me. I'm desperate for some answers as I can't stand seeing my son like this any longer.

Thank you for taking your time to read my email.